Our 17″ MacBook Pro Stolen by UPS Employee - Why UPS Needs GPS Package Tracking
News, GPS January 31st, 2008Well this is not what I had originally intended this post for. Let me quickly detail my original plans and then what actually ended up happening. First off, we were trying to ship a 17″ MacBook Pro to a co-worker in Austin. We thought about having a little fun and sending the SPOT Satellite Messenger I received for Christmas along with it. This would allow us to track the package with roughly a location reading every 10 minutes. We’d be able to watch the package as it moved within the Ublip fleet tracking app, though we were very skeptical of it ever sending a reading since it would be indoors (or inside a truck) most of the time. But hey, it was the beginning of a cool experiment.
So here are where things go a bit awry. Here’s a pic of the UPS store I shipped from:
Click the image to see the store’s location. Next I snapped a pic of the MacBook along with the SPOT device:

I originally took this photo with excitement as I’d be able to blog about how we tracked the MacBook all the way to Austin using our location tracking software. Boy was I wrong about that. So I turn on the SPOT and walk into the store. I put the power cable and SPOT in a small box as not to draw attention to the flashing LEDs on the device.
The guy behind the counter (the store manager) asks me where the computer is going and I give him all the details. He weighs it and asks me how much I’d like to insure it for. I’m going to be completely honest here and admit my first mistake. I tell him that I’d like to insure it for $1,000. As you may or may not already know, the 17″ MacBook Pro can easily set you back $3,000. Now let me justify my decision a bit. When asking for insurance I always work under the assumption that I’m having something insured against damage because of mishandling or some sort of accident. I own a PowerBook G4 and the worst damage I ever had with mine was getting the motherboard replaced after I dropped it. This cost a nice $900. Anyway, that was my somewhat weak reasoning.
I’d like to point out the store manager weighs the MacBook before putting it in the box and prints my invoice based on this weight (approx 7 lbs). That doesn’t seem to concern me too much, but when I ask him where’s the box so I can package the MacBook he tells me that they’ll do it behind the counter. Since I’ve insured it they feel more comfortable taking on the responsibility of packaging it themselves, than letting me do it. That seems like a reasonable policy and I’ve done this on several occasions in the past, but never with such an expensive piece of equipment. My second mistake was to trust this in their hands and walk out of the store without ever seeing them package the MacBook. It’s all good, so I drive back to the office to login to our GPS tracking app to see if the SPOT had reported. No report. No big deal as I was very skeptical we’d ever get a report in the first place.
The next day I’m at dinner with a friend and I get a call from Austin. Austin was the recipient of the package and he lives in Austin. Austin says to me, “Hey, did you forget to put the MacBook in the box?” This kind of throws me for a loop and I say to him “What in the word are you talking about?” He then proceeds to tell me that there’s an empty box with the SPOT tracker inside, but nothing else. My first reaction was of complete astonishment. So we talk through the situation some more and I try not to presume the worst, that the MacBook had been stolen. So I ask Austin to snap some pics and send them to me.
This first pic is of the box after Austin opened it. The box looked perfectly sealed and everything, just weighed about 7lbs less!

This pic is of the bubble wrap the MacBook was apparently in:

Here’s a pic of the small box I packed the SPOT device and the power cable in. This was inside the big box with the MacBook. As you can see, there’s no power cable:

And last but not least, a random zip lock bag (that’s right kids, a zip lock bag!) that Austin found inside the box:

A rather humorous point I’d like to make is that the SPOT tracker was still blinking when it arrived at Austin’s doorstep. I had put it in continuous tracking mode before I shipped it from the UPS store in Dallas. That means some idiot had to open the box, pull out the power supply, while a GPS tracker was sitting right there next to it. If ONLY the friggin’ SPOT would have reported JUST THAT ONE TIME!
Our other theory is that since I was such an idiot and left the store without ever watching the MacBook get boxed up is that it never made it into the box. When I called the store manager the next day he sounded very nonchalant about the whole situation and mentioned that this is somewhat common during the Holiday season. I was baffled to hear this and it blows my mind that our MacBook was stolen by a UPS employee. When I went into the store just to get clarification on the situation the lady was very offended by some of the questions I asked such as:
- Do you have confirmation that the computer actually left the store?
- Is the weight of the package monitored at each check point?
- Will we be reimbursed for the full cost of the computer?
At any rate, I thought I had every right to do my own sort of investigation since a $3,000 piece of hardware just turned up missing. I asked the store manager what comes next and he informed me they would tell UPS of the situation. From my understanding UPS stores are independently owned and operated.
After UPS was notified they would send a fraud investigator to Austin’s house to pick up the package and inspect it. We were informed that if everything goes well we should get our $1,000 claim check. When I heard this I almost flipped my lid (hence my reference to mistake #1 above). They’re going to reimburse us a measly $1,000 because one of UPS’ employees stole our MacBook? When buying insurance never in a million years did I think to insure it against theft from the company I was shipping with.
I really am not interested in pointing the finger because I do realize mistakes happen. But the least UPS could do is refund us the cost of the MacBook. At the time of this post we’re waiting to hear back from UPS regarding our $1,000 insurance check, but I’m kinda hoping this post raises a little more awareness within their organization. I will post an update once I hear from UPS.
Here’s what I did learn in this entire process:
- If you ship high-value goods with UPS I would recommend insuring them for their total value. It sucks that you may need to insure them for their retail value, not what they’re currently worth.
- The SPOT Satellite Messenger is not a reliable device to do package tracking with. That’s not its intended purpose, but I thought it would be a cool experiment.
- Always watch the person at the front package your item or do it yourself before you get into the store.
- UPS really needs to consider a GPS tracking solution for high-value goods. I know a great company that could help them with this (check out www.ublip.com - my shameless plug).
I would like to ask anyone that reads this article to please share their thoughts on the following:
- From the information I’ve shared, where do you think our MacBook is? Do you think it’s with someone at the UPS store or possibly stolen by a UPS driver?
- Have you ever experienced a similar situation?
- Do you think UPS should refund us for the full cost of the MacBook?
I’d love to hear your thoughts and hope you enjoyed the rather eventful post. I can say that it’s been a very eventful last week and everyone that hears this story stares at me in disbelief.



January 31st, 2008 at 5:53 am
while it really sux that someone jacked your macbook pro, i personally dont think that UPS should refund you the full value. they are a huge company with thounds of employees. they cannot honestly be expected to babysit every single person constantly. if i had to ship something as valuable as this i would have packeaged it before i took it into the ups store. that way you eliminate as much as posible anyone knowing whats inside. i guess you should consider yourself that you insured it for $1000 and not less, or at all for that fact
January 31st, 2008 at 6:47 am
That’s a valid point. I guess it was a $2,000 (assuming we get our $1,000 refund) lesson for me to learn to pre-package something like this before I ship from there again. I’m just curious to know that if it was ripped off during transit how would someone know what’s actually inside? The contents of the package was marked “laptop”, but surely thousands of laptops get moved around UPS on a daily basis. It just seems odd they would target this one box, but what do I know.
January 31st, 2008 at 4:38 pm
Obviously you haven’t shipped laptops around too much. I would *never* let a UPS store do any more than hand me the box in which to ship the computer. I *always* do my own packing and I never label them as “computer”. I always label them as “electronic gear” and I always insure for full retail value. I also mark things fragile. Inside the box I put security tape across the interior so that should anyone tamper with the box, the security tape will be broken and it will be obvious if the box itself arrives. I’ve had no trouble shipping at least a dozen laptops to my children in other parts of the country, or to eBay purchasers as far away as Poland. Of course, I’m always anal about retaining original shipping containers for computers as they contain all the correct packing material.
This was a really expensive lesson for you. I bet you don’t make it again. And don’t expect UPS to reimburse you for more than what you insured the computer for. After all, the prima facie evidence of what YOU thought the computer was worth was the amount of insurance you purchased. Penny wise; pound foolish. Better to overinsure than to do what you did. When disaster strikes, it is usually worse than you ever imagine, especially today with the volume of packages shipped around the country.
January 31st, 2008 at 8:04 pm
You know what it whould be good.
If the serial number could somehow invoke an alarm back routing IP address to the origin when this macbook actually get into SOFTWARE update method, manaually or automaticaly.
Assuming you have registered and kept somewhere your serial number (the invoice should have it) you report it’s theft to apple and they record it as stolen in their databases !
maybe this way it whould make no sense to steal a computer. Same applies to mobiles with the IMEI number. it whould help a lot.
There could be the case though where a software could alter the serial using a boot disk. Could it.
I sure hope you find your laptop and that SPOT thing did really help at all !!
Cheers
January 31st, 2008 at 9:16 pm
Trevor, it is a well founded legal and moral principle that companies are responsible for the actions of ALL of their employees, especially while on the job. While I agree that Dennis made several naive mistakes and I also wouldn’t hold my breath waiting for UPS to pay up, I find the acceptance of this crime appalling. I cannot understand what system of ethics could say a small company should be held responsible for criminal activity, but not a large one because it would be too difficult.
January 31st, 2008 at 10:36 pm
George, thanks for the heads up. We’ll definitely report it to Apple as stolen, but I’m fairly confident that the MacBook made it’s way quickly to a pawn shop or the black market.
February 1st, 2008 at 6:48 pm
I would like to know the location of this store (crossroads only)since i am in the dallas area. I truly would not want to ship from this location from all of what has been commented so far. I would be interested on the outcome of this incident and will monitor this to see if there is a positive outcome.
February 1st, 2008 at 10:12 pm
Mickey,
If you click on the image of the store above you’ll see where it is (Preston/Belt Line area). I’m trying not to hold blame to the individual store, but this should raise awareness. I’ll post the outcome when we have one.
February 1st, 2008 at 11:23 pm
There is a company in Irving Texas called SAVR Communications that I know is working on a High Value Asset tracking solution with carriers like UPS and DHL, just like one that would have helped in this situation. Just go to www.savrcom.com
February 1st, 2008 at 11:25 pm
That really sucks. We have been bitten by the same issue about under-insuring goods for transport, I feel your pain. Next time you guys are going to ship something of value, use one of our Sentry tracking units. We have already had several successful runs tracking inside UPS and other carrier vehicles, even in the distribution centers! www.savrcom.com
February 17th, 2008 at 9:04 pm
I think you should contact the UPS Public Relations people. If you raise hell those will ultimately be the people that will most likely react. Even this blog entry is really bad publicity. I understand the UPS is a big company and damages can happen, but losing packages all together? That’s absurd. What does it mean to ship through a company who can’t even guarantee that the contents of your shipment will make it to the other end? Sure shit happens breaks, but theft? That’s just excessively irresponsible.
I’m sure there employees have to abide by zero-tolerance theft policy, but what good is the policy is not enforced.
How do the businesses ensure their gear is safely sent to their customers? Do they ensure it full value? I’m sure if a FedEx employee stole a brand macbook pro (it wouldn’t be hard to do. They all ship from Shanghai CN to Anchorage, AK. They ship so damn many of them through there I wouldn’t be surprised if it was hard to recognize the dimensions of the boxes) and it didn’t get to the consumer on time. Apple would be severely pissed. FedEx would react quickly to ensure Apple still has their business.
You should have your local UPS check surveillance tapes of who “wrapped” your package. I imagine there was video of you handing over the package at the service counter. I have a strong feeling that employee would have a good idea of where it is.
I’m just surprised how little they hold their employees accountable. That there automatically gives employees an incentive to steal. Theft is based on incentives…if the risks are low-enough, it’ll happen.
February 18th, 2008 at 1:51 pm
Jeff,
Thanks for the thoughts. I was told that there is 24/7 surveillance so it may be worth asking them to pull the tapes. I’ll post what I find out.
February 29th, 2008 at 6:20 pm
I have the same problem ( or not exactly ). Some high valued jewelry that were shipped from India to Canada. I also undervalued it by 2700$, and strangely just after they scanned it at night for clearing it disappeared. I have notified UPS which is looking for it, but they seem not to respond too much. Luckily it is in the same city for what it is worth. Lesson: Never, ever ship with UPS again.
March 11th, 2008 at 4:05 pm
[…] six weeks ago our MacBook Pro was stolen by a UPS employee during transit. At least that was our suspicion, but evidence points out that it may have never […]